最高法民一庭《民事审判指导与参考》中提到：https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n“建设工程施工合同以交付符合合同约定、质量合格的劳动成果——建设工程为标的；劳务合同以提供劳务为标的，至于该劳务是否产生一个具体的劳动成果，在所不问。”https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n说明区分劳务分包合同和劳务合同，最主要看——是否有交付成果的要求。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n合同标的与工作内容区分要点https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n1. 标的范围https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n• 劳务分包合同：以完成特定专业工程劳务作业为核心，如砌筑、焊接、钢筋绑扎等专业技术性工作，需符合行业技术规范。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n• 劳务合同（劳务雇佣）：以提供基础劳动力为目标，如搬运建材、场地清扫、杂工协助等非技术性服务，不涉及专业技术标准。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n2. 独立性https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n• 劳务分包合同：分包方需独立组织人员、技术和管理完成作业，在施工中具有自主性（如安排工时、调配工人）。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n• 劳务合同（劳务雇佣）：劳务人员完全接受发包方直接指挥管理，无独立决策权（如上下班时间、工作内容由发包方决定）。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n3. 材料与设备归属https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n• 劳务分包合同：https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n◦ 主要建筑材料（如水泥、钢筋）由总包方提供；https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n◦ 分包方通常自带小型机具（如焊机、手持工具）。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n• 劳务合同（劳务雇佣）：https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n◦ 发包方提供全部材料及大型施工设备（如塔吊、搅拌机）；https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n◦ 劳务人员仅提供体力劳动，无需携带工具。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n实务中需结合合同约定、实际履行方式及行业惯例综合认定。https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n https://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cnhttps://www.rc.tj.cn\n#法院人 #法官助理 #职场干货 #法律实务 #建筑工程 #劳务分包 #律师
